Descriptor
Comparative Analysis | 11 |
Indexes | 11 |
Periodicals | 5 |
Reference Materials | 5 |
Information Retrieval | 4 |
Tables (Data) | 4 |
Abstracts | 3 |
Evaluation | 3 |
Information Services | 3 |
Book Reviews | 2 |
Evaluation Methods | 2 |
More ▼ |
Source
RQ | 11 |
Author
Palmer, Joseph W. | 2 |
Brownson, Charles W. | 1 |
Chaney, Suzanne F. | 1 |
Koch, Loretta | 1 |
Lingenfelter, Judith | 1 |
Mesplay, Deborah | 1 |
Milby, T. H. | 1 |
Reese, Carol | 1 |
Robinson, Wendy | 1 |
Spencer, Michael D. G. | 1 |
Swenk, Cynthia | 1 |
More ▼ |
Publication Type
Journal Articles | 9 |
Reports - Research | 7 |
Reports - Evaluative | 2 |
Book/Product Reviews | 1 |
Reference Materials -… | 1 |
Tests/Questionnaires | 1 |
Education Level
Audience
Researchers | 2 |
Media Staff | 1 |
Practitioners | 1 |
Location
Laws, Policies, & Programs
Assessments and Surveys
What Works Clearinghouse Rating

Milby, T. H. – RQ, 1972
A study of Biological Abstracts" and Index to American Botanical Literature" was made to determine: (1) the degree of overlap in coverage between the two services and (2) the time lapse between the publication of an article and its appearance in one of the indexes. (8 references) (NH)
Descriptors: Biology, Comparative Analysis, Indexes, Information Services

Chaney, Suzanne F. – RQ, 1981
Describes a comparative survey of Ulrich's International Periodicals Directory and the Guide to Microforms in Print which indicated that the information on microform availability given by Ulrich's is not accurate. The results of the comparison are summarized in a table. (JL)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Indexes, Library Materials, Microforms

Wyndham, Diana – RQ, 1980
Ulrich's performance in listing references to indexes was tested by comparing its statement of where a journal is indexed with the list of the indexed journals in the indexing/abstracting services themselves. (Author)
Descriptors: Abstracts, Comparative Analysis, Evaluation, Indexes

Palmer, Joseph W. – RQ, 1979
Compares "Book Review Digest,""Book Review Index," and "Current Book Review Citations" for their coverage of titles appearing on the best-seller lists of "Publishers Weekly." Methodology is described and results are provided for both 1976 and 1978 titles. (Author/JD)
Descriptors: Book Reviews, Comparative Analysis, Evaluation, Evaluation Criteria

Swenk, Cynthia; Robinson, Wendy – RQ, 1978
This study investigated the accuracy of these services: whether they excluded sources in which a journal was actually indexed; and whether the journals accurately reported which services indexed them. (Author/JAB)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Guides, Indexes, Information Services

Brownson, Charles W. – RQ, 1983
Indexes to literature published in English-language little magazines are analyzed for duplication and completeness of coverage, and the number of little magazines founded since 1900 is estimated to determine the extent of literary work accessible by means of indexes. A 50-item annotated list of information sources and 12 references are included.
Descriptors: Annotated Bibliographies, Comparative Analysis, Indexes, Information Retrieval

Spencer, Michael D. G. – RQ, 1986
This discussion of the failure to include many book reviews by indexes in selected subject fields and by several general indexes highlights the technique used to check review materials in selected magazines to see what was actually indexed, the policies of specific indexes, and the practical consequences for librarians. (EM)
Descriptors: Book Reviews, Comparative Analysis, Content Analysis, Indexes

Mesplay, Deborah; Koch, Loretta – RQ, 1993
Evaluates the coverage provided by eight indexing and abstracting services in the interdisciplinary field of women's studies. Content pages for 17 women's studies journals were checked against appropriate indexes to determine the comprehensiveness of coverage, and "Women Studies Abstract" was found to provide the best coverage. (15…
Descriptors: Abstracting, Comparative Analysis, Evaluation Methods, Indexes

Reese, Carol – RQ, 1988
The relative effectiveness of the CD-ROM information retrieval system, InfoTrac II, and the manual "Readers' Guide to Periodical Literature," was studied. Seventeen community college students were divided into two groups which researched the same questions either on CD-ROM or in the printed index. Results showed the "Readers'…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Indexes, Information Retrieval

Lingenfelter, Judith; And Others – RQ, 1981
Presents an evaluative analysis of five indexing/abstracting services covering sports and physical education. Data on the scope, arrangement, indexing language, journal coverage, subject access, special features, and use aids in each of the services are presented in four tables. (JL)
Descriptors: Abstracts, Athletics, Comparative Analysis, Conference Proceedings

Palmer, Joseph W. – RQ, 1992
An examination of OCLC's EPIC service and standard video reference tools revealed that EPIC was more comprehensive in finding video titles on the popular or specialized topics of bonsai, genealogy, karate, and holography, because of its keyword searching ability on the massive OCLC database. (11 references) (EA)
Descriptors: Abstracts, Cataloging, Comparative Analysis, Costs