This research examines doctoral student perceptions of emotional exhaustion relative to supportive supervision and the use of impression management (IM) and facades of conformity (FOC). Results indicated that supportive supervision significantly reduced emotional exhaustion and the use of self-presentation behaviours, while the use of FOC increased emotional exhaustion. Qualitative data additionally indicate that doctoral students use FOC due to differing values and academic goals, as well as to the desire to finish their programme. IM is used in order to finish the degree, to avoid confrontation and out of respect for a supervisor's role and experience. In sum, results indicate that supportive supervision and the ability for doctoral students to "be themselves" should reduce doctoral student emotional exhaustion and self-presentation behaviours, thus leading to better student outcomes.