Due to the tremendous attack of the COVID-19 pandemic worldwide, educational institutions struggled noticeably to cope with its associated predicament. In the initial stage of the pandemic attack, knowledge about Coronavirus and its socio-economic effects was scarce, and school leaders lacked adequate training on crisis management during a pandemic. Thus, the pandemic posed a dilemma and an ultimate test for educational leaders worldwide. This study aimed to explore the challenges secondary school leaders in Bangladesh encountered during the COVID-19 pandemic, and their leadership strategies to cope with the crisis. The 'measurement model of crisis leadership' was applied as the conceptual framework. Using a qualitative approach and thematic analysis framework for data analysis, the study revealed leaders' considerable academic, financial, and socio-emotional challenges. The leaders were found to apply certain crisis leadership attributes consistent with the 'measurement model of crisis leadership'. However, the study identified the absence of inclusiveness' in the framework, thereby proposing the inclusion of 'equity and social justice' in the existing framework since leaders' ability to ensure equal access to all students appeared essential during the crisis. Finally, this study brings the recommendations for policy-level reformation in school leadership training on crisis management in Bangladesh to develop leaders' competence for managing risk effectively and maximizing risk-reduction actions required during critical times.