In this essay, I offer William James's notion of pragmatic belief as a framework for re-envisioning religious discourses as rhetorical resources in composition teaching. Adopting a Jamesian pragmatic framework in composition teaching, I argue, entails two pragmatic adjustments to current approaches. The first adjustment concerns the way we think about the relationship between academic discourse and religious discourse. And the second adjustment relates to the stances we adopt when responding to religious students' texts. Along with outlining these adjustments, I illustrate the ways James's framework productively informed my response to a faith-based narrative that an evangelical student wrote in one of my first-year writing courses. (Contains 6 notes.)