Lauds Haggerson's critique of the author's instructional supervision research issues article for substantiating Hill's contention that interpretivist and "rationalist" methodologies are compatible and can be integrated into a single approach. Assails Scheurich and Lather's article for labeling Hill's position "positivist,"…

Clinical supervision remained grounded in empirical inquiry as late as Morris Cogan's writings on the subject in 1973. With the acknowledgment of Thomas Kuhn's (1962) paradigm shift, educational theory and practice developed interpretive methodologies. An interpretive reflection on Cogan's rationale offers insights into the current, matured…

Jean Hill's article in the same "Journal of Curriculum and Supervision" issue critiques the interpretivists' alleged ambiguities, contradictions, and uncritically held assumptions, based on the a priori assumptions of his own positivist paradigm. Critical theorists would deplore the exclusion of Marxism, feminism, and race-specific…

Reviews the "Journal of Curriculum and Supervision" Spring 1990 issue from a scientific viewpoint. This article found ambiguous word meanings, apparent contradictions in and among several authors' writings, an artificially dichotomous formulation of the relationship between two complementary inquiry methods and uncritically held…