In experiments with paired comparisons, judges are occasionally allowed to express indifference between alternatives. For the analysis of such data, models for paired comparisons with ties are needed. Several models with tie parameters are reviewed. All are extensions of the basic models of L. L. Thurstone (1927) and R. A. Bradley and M. E. Terry…

Several goodness of fit (GOF) criteria have been developed to assist the researcher in interpreting structural equation models. However, the determination of GOF for structural equation models is not as straightforward as that for other statistical approaches in multivariate procedures. The four GOF criteria used across the commonly used…

Type I error rates were estimated for three tests that compare means by using data from two independent samples: the independent samples t test, Welch's approximate degrees of freedom test, and James's second order test. Type I error rates were estimated for skewed distributions, equal and unequal variances, equal and unequal sample sizes, and a…

Describes and compares eight methods of estimating the parameters of the Zipf distribution. (CLB)

Two methods of estimating parameters in the Rasch model are compared. The equivalence of likelihood estimations from the model of G. J. Mellenbergh and P. Vijn (1981) and from usual unconditional maximum likelihood (UML) estimation is demonstrated. Mellenbergh and Vijn's model is a convenient method of calculating UML estimates. (SLD)

Section Pre-Equating (SPE) is a method used to equate test forms that consist of multiple separately timed sections. SPE does not require examinees to take two complete forms of the test. Instead, all of the old form and one or two sections of the new form are administered to each examinee, and missing data techniques are employed to estimate the…

The benefits of item response theory (IRT) will only accrue to a testing program to the extent that model assumptions are met. Obtaining accurate item parameter estimates is a critical first step. However, the sample sizes required for stable parameter estimation are often difficult to obtain in practice, particularly for the more complex models.…

This paper considers the following questions: (1) what is the relationship between the method of paired comparisons and Rasch measurement theory? (2) what is the relationship between the method of paired comparisons and graph theory? and (3) what can graph theory contribute to the understanding of Rasch measurement theory? It is specifically shown…

Log-linear model bivariate smoothing and a bivariate smoothing model based on the four-parameter beta binomial model were compared for usefulness in frequency estimation common-item equipercentile equating using two datasets. The performance of smoothed equipercentile methods was also compared to that of linear methods of common-item equating.…

Using computer simulated data, the Type I error rate and statistical power were empirically estimated for several pairwise multiple comparison strategies for situations where population variances differ. Focus was on comparing modified Bonferroni procedures with Dunnett's solutions, and determining whether or not J. P. Shaffer's suggestion of…

The purpose of this paper is to illustrate the use of tobit analysis and tobit decomposition in educational research. Tobit estimates of growth rate in the presence of a ceiling effect were compared with ordinary least squares (OLS) and weighted least squares (WLS) estimates. The tobit estimates had the smallest standard error, the smallest bias,…

Monte Carlo simulation compared chi-square statistics, parameter estimates, and root mean square error of approximation values using normal and elliptical estimation methods. Three research conditions were imposed on the simulated data: sample size, population contamination percent, and kurtosis. A Bentler-Weeks structural model established the…

A method of comparing one-step M-estimates of location for heavy tailed distributions is proposed and investigated. Simulations indicate that the new procedure provides good control over Type I errors and has more power than do some other methods for dealing with heavy tailed distributions. (SLD)

E.J. Bedrick recently derived the asymptotic distribution of the modified sample biserial correlation estimator of F.M. Lord and studied its efficacy for bivariate normal populations. A more detailed examination of the properties of Lord's estimator is provided, and the small sample bias and variance are studied. (SLD)

Across conditions, differences between population parameters defined by common factor analysis and component analysis are demonstrated. Implications for data analytic and theoretical issues related to choice of analytic model are discussed. Results suggest that principal components analysis should not be used to obtain parameters reflecting latent…