Descriptor
Comparative Analysis | 40 |
Tables (Data) | 40 |
Indexing | 28 |
Information Retrieval | 21 |
Automatic Indexing | 14 |
Relevance (Information… | 14 |
Subject Index Terms | 14 |
Search Strategies | 11 |
Databases | 9 |
Online Searching | 9 |
Indexes | 6 |
More ▼ |
Source
Author
Publication Type
Journal Articles | 37 |
Reports - Research | 36 |
Book/Product Reviews | 2 |
Information Analyses | 2 |
Opinion Papers | 2 |
Speeches/Meeting Papers | 2 |
Dissertations/Theses -… | 1 |
Reference Materials -… | 1 |
Reports - Descriptive | 1 |
Education Level
Location
Australia | 1 |
Netherlands | 1 |
Saudi Arabia | 1 |
Laws, Policies, & Programs
Assessments and Surveys
What Works Clearinghouse Rating

Pao, Miranda Lee – Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 1978
Describes a method of selecting index terms directly from a word frequency list, an idea originally suggested by Goffman. Results of the analysis of word frequencies of two articles seem to indicate that the automated selection of index terms from a frequency list holds some promise for automatic indexing. (Author/MBR)
Descriptors: Automatic Indexing, Comparative Analysis, Experiments, Indexing
Sonnenfeld, Gary F. – 1990
This paper is a content analysis of three general encyclopedias, "Encyclopedia Americana" (EA), "Encyclopaedia Brittanica" (EB), and "World Book Encyclopedia" (WBC), which quantifies the treatment of the occult. Entries are selected from each by starting with the article "Occultism" and tracing all…
Descriptors: Bias, Comparative Analysis, Content Analysis, Encyclopedias

Veenema, Fred – Canadian Journal of Information and Library Science, 1996
Describes an experiment comparing the performance of an automatic full-text indexing software for personal computers (i.e., the Quick-Finder facility in WordPerfect 6.1 for Windows) with the human intellectual assignment of indexing terms to each document in a collection. Results are discussed in terms of ease of use, the time factor, and recall…
Descriptors: Automatic Indexing, Comparative Analysis, Computer Software Evaluation, Indexes

Seymour, R. J.; Yates-Mercer, Penelope A. – Information Processing and Management, 1980
Reports a study that examined 10 collections of mainly scientific subject areas indexed using Farradane's system of relational indexing. It compared (1) the use of relations, (2) the use of concept types, (3) the cross sections (or shape) of abstracts, and (4) the properties of "nodes." Statistical tables and graphs are included.…
Descriptors: Abstracts, Comparative Analysis, Indexing, Information Retrieval

Wiberley, Stephen E., Jr. – Library Quarterly, 1988
Explores differences in precision of terms used in subject access in the humanities, differentiating by the exactness with which the phenomena designated can be located in space and time. Samples of 200 terms from seven indexes in the humanities are classified according to five categories of terms. Six tables present results of data analyses. (22…
Descriptors: Classification, Comparative Analysis, Humanities, Indexes

Rasheed, Muhammad Abdur – International Library Review, 1989
Describes a study that compared indexing terms suggested by authors of articles in "The American Journal of the Medical Science" and indexing terms assigned to the same articles in MEDLARS. Case studies are used to examine the differences between author and indexer indexing. (CLB)
Descriptors: Authors, Case Studies, Comparative Analysis, Indexing

Konings, C. A. G. – Online Review, 1985
This comparison of bibliographies/online databases regarding their classification schemes, periodicals list, coverage of articles, indexing, and overlap reveals that only five bibliographies cover whole of subject area, and differences exist between number of periodicals scanned (73 to 2,771) and percentage of articles included from six…
Descriptors: Bibliographies, Classification, Comparative Analysis, Computer Science

Brooks, Terrence A. – Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 1993
This test of the Strategy of Unlimited Aliasing, an indexing method that places terms from several indexers for the same information object in one index, utilized bibliographic records from the ERIC, LISA (Library and Information Science Abstracts), and ISA (Information Science Abstracts) databases. The test did not support the indexing method.…
Descriptors: Bibliographic Databases, Comparative Analysis, Indexing, Information Retrieval

de Jong-Hofman, M. W. – Online Review, 1981
In order to compare effects of input processing on information retrieval in three databases, 25 articles from a specific journal were examined. Tables and Venn diagrams show retrieval results from different manual and computer searches. The relation between document surrogates and subject matter of the documents is discussed. (SW)
Descriptors: Abstracting, Comparative Analysis, Databases, Indexing
Edwards, Tom, Ed. – 1975
Six major indexing and abstracting services were studied to isolate similarities and differences, obtain raw data, and attempt to estimate primary material covered by the services. The 1973 issues of all services were examined and statistics were obtained for periodical and non-periodical entries. Data were analyzed and the services compared by:…
Descriptors: Abstracting, Comparative Analysis, Indexing, Information Science

Middleton, Michael R.; Di'Orio, Aurora – Behavioral & Social Sciences Librarian, 1984
References indexed for Australian Education Index (AEI) were sampled and compared where possible with same references indexed for ERIC and Australian Public Affairs Information Service (APAIS) databases. An analysis of coverage of Australian references reveals indexing consistency figures of 22 percent for ERIC/AEI and 18 percent for AEI/APAIS.…
Descriptors: Citations (References), Comparative Analysis, Databases, Foreign Countries

Crouch, Carolyn J. – Information Processing and Management, 1988
Describes the two basic approaches to the calculation of term discrimination values for automatic indexing. The results of an experiment that investigated the differences between algorithms of these two approaches in terms of their impact on the discrimination value model are reported and discussed. (13 references) (Author/CLB)
Descriptors: Algorithms, Automatic Indexing, Comparative Analysis, Computational Linguistics

Lochbaum, Karen E.; Streeter, Lynn A. – Information Processing and Management, 1989
Describes experiments that compared a new method for automatically analyzing semantic structures in text by statistical means with the standard vector space model. Findings indicate that combining both methods improved performance over either alone. The effects of other experimental variables on retrieval performance (term weighting, suffix…
Descriptors: Automatic Indexing, Comparative Analysis, Computational Linguistics, Information Retrieval
Stieg, Margaret F.; Atkinson, Joan L. – Library Journal, 1988
Considers the quality of bibliographic control achieved by the three online databases offering significant coverage of the literature of librarianship: ERIC, LISA, and Library Literature. Focusing on coverage and indexing, the study compares online search results with the tables of contents of 67 journals and reports the results. (27 references)…
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Databases, Indexing, Online Searching

Giral, Angela; Taylor, Arlene G. – Library Resources and Technical Services, 1993
Examines the overlap of article coverage and the consistency of indexing between the "Avery Index to Architectural Periodicals" and the "Architectural Periodicals Index." The historical backgrounds of the two indexes are described, possibilities for collaboration between them are considered, and implications for users are…
Descriptors: Architecture, Comparative Analysis, Cooperation, Indexes