There is currently limited evidence regarding teachers' perspectives of push-in and pull-out occupational therapy services in the school-based setting. Occupational therapy services can be delivered in different combinations and often vary based on the needs of the student, needs of the teacher and classroom, need for academic time, and need for social interactions. To examine teachers' perspectives of push-in and pull-out services, a qualitative approach was used. Thirty-nine participants were recruited using a combination of convenience, snowball, purposive, and voluntary response sampling. Data was collected via a multiple choice and open response online survey. Thematic analysis was completed with the identification of six themes. Pros and cons of both push-in and pull-out service delivery, carryover, and modifications were discussed. Conclusively, most teachers preferred a combination of push-in and pull-out services, highlighting the importance of communication, collaboration, carryover, and finding the just-right fit for each student to best support their needs and learning styles. The findings of this study will better provide school-based occupational therapy practitioners with context for selecting the most appropriate service delivery model for each student.