Preequating is in demand because it reduces score reporting time. In this article, we evaluated an observed-score preequating method: the empirical item characteristic curve (EICC) method, which makes preequating without item response theory (IRT) possible. EICC preequating results were compared with a criterion equating and with IRT true-score preequating conversions. Results suggested that the EICC preequating method worked well under the conditions considered in this study. The difference between the EICC preequating conversion and the criterion equating was smaller than 0.5 raw-score points (a practical criterion often used to evaluate equating quality) between the 5th and 95th percentiles of the new form total score distribution. EICC preequating also performed similarly or slightly better than IRT true-score preequating.