Descriptor
Comparative Analysis | 13 |
Optical Data Disks | 13 |
Questionnaires | 13 |
Higher Education | 8 |
User Satisfaction… | 8 |
Databases | 7 |
Indexes | 7 |
Academic Libraries | 5 |
Online Searching | 5 |
Search Strategies | 5 |
Use Studies | 5 |
More ▼ |
Source
Reference Librarian | 2 |
Journal of the American… | 1 |
Laserdisk Professional | 1 |
Microcomputers for… | 1 |
RQ | 1 |
Reference Services Review | 1 |
Author
Bevis, Mary D. | 2 |
Blackburn, Jennifer O. | 1 |
Chen, Ching-chih | 1 |
Compton, Lawrence E. | 1 |
El-Hadidy, Bahaa | 1 |
Forrest, Charles | 1 |
Meyer, Nikki | 1 |
Nassar, Nancy | 1 |
Raitt, David | 1 |
Reese, Carol | 1 |
Steffey, Ramona J. | 1 |
More ▼ |
Publication Type
Tests/Questionnaires | 11 |
Reports - Research | 9 |
Journal Articles | 7 |
Dissertations/Theses | 2 |
Dissertations/Theses -… | 2 |
Information Analyses | 1 |
Reports - Evaluative | 1 |
Education Level
Audience
Researchers | 1 |
Location
Europe | 1 |
Guyana | 1 |
United States | 1 |
Laws, Policies, & Programs
Assessments and Surveys
What Works Clearinghouse Rating

Reese, Carol – RQ, 1988
The relative effectiveness of the CD-ROM information retrieval system, InfoTrac II, and the manual "Readers' Guide to Periodical Literature," was studied. Seventeen community college students were divided into two groups which researched the same questions either on CD-ROM or in the printed index. Results showed the "Readers'…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Indexes, Information Retrieval

Bevis, Mary D. – Reference Librarian, 1996
Describes a study conducted at Jacksonville State University (Alabama) that compared the ERIC print index, "Resources in Education" (RIE), to the ERIC index in CD-ROM format. Accuracy of results, time savings, and user satisfaction are discussed, and copies of the questionnaire and survey are appended. (Author/LRW)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Indexes, Optical Data Disks, Printed Materials

Bevis, Mary D. – Reference Librarian, 1996
Describes a study conducted at Jacksonville State University (Alabama) that compared the ERIC print index with the ERIC index in CD-ROM format in the areas of accuracy, time savings, and user satisfaction. Results show greater satisfaction with CD-ROM. Copies of the questionnaire and survey used are appended. (Author/LRW)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Higher Education, Indexes, Optical Data Disks
Compton, Lawrence E. – 1991
This study investigated the use patterns of four CD-ROM systems--Newsbank Electronic Index, SilverPlatter's ERIC and PsycLIT, and Dissertation Abstracts Ondisc--and their print index counterparts in the University of Georgia (UGA) Main Library, which houses collections and provides library services for the humanities, the social sciences, and…
Descriptors: College Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Databases, Higher Education
Stout, Sheri A. – 1993
This study compares ABI/INFORM and Wilson Business Abstracts in order to determine user preference. Surveys in the form of questionnaires were used to evaluate users' preference of interface, database response time, search results and ease of use with both business CD-ROM databases. Kent State University students, faculty, and patrons interested…
Descriptors: Chi Square, College Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Database Producers

El-Hadidy, Bahaa – Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 1994
Describes a case study which explored the extent to which CD-ROM products can support the information needs in developing countries; assessed the economics of a system of CD-ROM databases supplemented by an online system; and investigated the breakeven analysis of the costs of searching CD-ROM versus online. (Contains 34 references.) (LRW)
Descriptors: Case Studies, Comparative Analysis, Cost Effectiveness, Costs
Steffey, Ramona J.; Meyer, Nikki – Laserdisk Professional, 1989
Describes a survey of users of three academic libraries that examined users' reactions to CD-ROM products and compared their satisfaction with different products. Some of the evaluation criteria used include ease of use, satisfaction with the number and quality of citations retrieved, and time spent searching. The survey form is appended. (eight…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Higher Education, Learning Strategies
Chen, Ching-chih; Raitt, David – Microcomputers for Information Management, 1990
Describes use studies of CD-ROM products in American and western European academic, public, and special libraries. Comparative results of the surveys are reported, including effect of CD-ROMs on library use of online databases, difficulties with different vendors' search techniques, and desired subjects of optical products. (10 references) (LRW)
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Databases, Foreign Countries

Forrest, Charles; And Others – Reference Services Review, 1989
Describes study that was designed to assess user interaction with InfoTrac, a computerized periodical index on optical disc that is accessed through workstations consisting of a microcomputer and printer. Use in three types of libraries--an undergraduate academic library, a graduate-level academic library, and a public library--is examined. (LRW)
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Computer Printers, Graduate Study
Blackburn, Jennifer O. – 1993
A survey of public library users was conducted regarding retrieval results of unassisted user searches in general periodical indexes. The data were analyzed to evaluate the impact or lack of impact of searching a CD-ROM index with loosely-controlled vocabulary and expanded-search capabilities (i.e., InfoTrac-General Periodicals Index) versus a…
Descriptors: Authority Control (Information), Comparative Analysis, Databases, Indexes
Straw, Joseph E. – 1993
This is a study of the research communities in history and political science at Kent State University (Ohio). The purpose is to provide a profile of historians and political scientists and to discover the kinds of information they use for research. A survey/questionnaire was circulated to the history and political science departments. Information…
Descriptors: College Faculty, Comparative Analysis, Databases, Educational Resources
Nassar, Nancy – 1988
A review of the literature was undertaken to determine whether purchasing DIALOG in the CD-ROM format or subscribing to the DIALOG online format would be the better solution for middle school students interested in information retrieval. This report begins by stating the problem and defining common computer terms. A review of the related…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Computer Literacy, Databases
Thrash, Beverly M. – 1993
This purpose of this study was to determine which periodical index--InfoTrac or EBSCO Magazine Article Summaries--is the most appropriate for use by middle school students preparing required research projects. The study population consisted of randomly selected sixth, seventh, and eighth grade students (N=50) in a Cobb County (Georgia) middle…
Descriptors: Bibliographic Databases, Comparative Analysis, Educational Resources, Indexes