In combinatorics, combinatorial notation, e.g., C(n, r), is explicitly defined as a numerical value, a cardinality. Yet, we do not use another symbol to signify the set of outcomes--the collection of objects being referenced, whose cardinality is, for example, C(n, r). For an expert, this duality in notation, of signifying both cardinality and…

In this paper we analyze common solutions that students often produce to isomorphic tasks involving proportional situations. We highlight some key distinctions across the tasks and between the different equations students write within each task to help elaborate the different interpretations of equivalence at play: numerical, transformational, and…

The literature concerning students' understanding of the equal sign has focused narrowly within the context of formal mathematics. Researchers have put forth a hierarchy of conceptions of the equal sign with only the top level regarded as correct. Meanwhile, we find that the equal sign is used widely and in a variety of ways in advertising and…

Mathematical conventions -- which account for the choices of mathematics community regarding definitions of concepts, their names and symbols -- are the focus of this paper. We introduce the task of unpacking, that is, offering plausible explanations and arguments for the choice of conventions. Using responses of four prospective teachers to the…

Drawing on the work of Gattegno, it is suggested that a powerful way of teaching mathematics is to introduce symbols as relationships between visible or tangible resources. The symbols are abstract (formal) from the beginning and yet there are concrete resources to support their use. Drawing on data from a research project in primary schools in…

In this article, I explore tensions of care in the context of school mathematics by examining two accounts of a classroom moment involving labelling an angle. In particular, I draw attention to how caring for students and caring for mathematical ideas interplay in complex ways by inquiring into the two accounts through ideas of care and…

I propose that attending how symbolizing activity functions for teachers and students helps to characterize student-teacher communication, and allows for an investigation of how symbolizing activity contributes to learning. I begin this discussion by articulating four ideas-schemes, symbolizing activity, communication, and learning. Then I propose…

The algebraic expertise that mathematics education is aiming for includes both procedural skills and conceptual understanding. To capture the latter, notions such as symbol sense, gestalt view and visual salience have been developed. We wonder if digital activities can be designed that not only require procedural algebraic skills, but also invite…

Uses Lacanian notions to create stories on the mathematics education topics of numeracy, symbolism, and desire. (MDH)

In this commentary on Matthew Inglis' "Three Worlds and the Imaginary Sphere" (see EJ1106688), David Tall develops the theme that the building of theories is not an easy process. A theory in progress is a particularly delicate creation. Theories do not appear fully formed. There is a period of exploration and incubation that precedes the…

Discusses algebra teaching by looking back into the history of algebra and the work of George Peacock, who considered algebra from two points of view: symbolic and instrumental. Claims that, to be meaningful, algebra must be linked to real-world problems. (18 references) (MKR)

Attempts to describe a notion parallel to number sense, called symbol sense, incorporating the following components: making friends with symbols, reading through symbols, engineering symbolic expressions, equivalent expressions for non-equivalent meanings, choice of symbols, flexible manipulation skills, symbols in retrospect, and symbols in…

Limitations in children's understanding of the symbols of arithmetic may inhibit choice of appropriate solution procedures. The teacher's role involves negotiation of new meanings for words and symbols to match extensions to solution procedures. (MKR)

Discussed is the importance of establishing the link between students' understanding of mathematics in real world settings and the symbolism used to represent that mathematics. Examples provide evidence that students and sometimes teachers fail to establish that link. References are given for resources providing strategies and contexts to assist…

Contends that, though much attention is given in mathematics to the problem of sensitizing people to the need for identifying elements of a situation and representing them symbolically, little or no effort is devoted to the problem of helping them express the relationships among these elements. (11 references) (MKR)