Publication Date
| In 2026 | 0 |
| Since 2025 | 56 |
| Since 2022 (last 5 years) | 397 |
| Since 2017 (last 10 years) | 1086 |
| Since 2007 (last 20 years) | 2107 |
Descriptor
Source
Author
Publication Type
Education Level
Audience
| Practitioners | 72 |
| Teachers | 56 |
| Policymakers | 48 |
| Administrators | 32 |
| Researchers | 29 |
| Parents | 21 |
| Students | 8 |
| Community | 7 |
| Counselors | 3 |
| Media Staff | 1 |
| Support Staff | 1 |
| More ▼ | |
Location
| Texas | 99 |
| Florida | 86 |
| California | 51 |
| Canada | 39 |
| North Carolina | 37 |
| New York | 32 |
| Turkey | 31 |
| United States | 31 |
| Australia | 30 |
| Texas (Austin) | 27 |
| China | 26 |
| More ▼ | |
Laws, Policies, & Programs
Assessments and Surveys
What Works Clearinghouse Rating
| Meets WWC Standards without Reservations | 1 |
| Meets WWC Standards with or without Reservations | 4 |
| Does not meet standards | 9 |
Peer reviewedCorman, H. – Economics of Education Review, 2003
Investigates the effects of state education policies on grade repetition rates. Finds, for example, that school entrance month has significant impact on probability of student having to repeat a grade, an impact due largely to the relative age of the student. Finds no impact of variations in state policies on grade repetition rates. (Contains 25…
Descriptors: Age Grade Placement, Educational Policy, Elementary Secondary Education, Family Characteristics
Peer reviewedHeubert, Jay P. – Educational Leadership, 2003
Argues that under certain conditions, high standards and demanding assessment can hurt rather than help low-achieving students. Discusses three practices educators and policymakers should avoid: requiring students to repeat a grade, placing students in low-track classes, and holding students accountable for material not yet taught. (Contains 13…
Descriptors: Accountability, Achievement Tests, Elementary Secondary Education, Grade Repetition
Peer reviewedPottorff, Donald D. – PTA Today, 1991
The academic benefits of grade retention are doubtful. Researchers have found that a low percentage of retained students achieve at a higher rate and that many regress. Parents should request a multidisciplinary evaluation before allowing a child to be retained. (JD)
Descriptors: Academic Achievement, Elementary Education, Emotional Development, Grade Repetition
Frymier, Jack; Gansneder, Bruce – Phi Delta Kappan, 1989
A recent "Kappan" Survey of 276 elementary, middle, and senior high schools found that between 25 to 35 percent of the 22,018 students surveyed are seriously at risk. Teachers and other staff dealing with at-risk students lacked confidence and information concerning students' lives. Grade retention practices proved detrimental to students.…
Descriptors: Administrator Responsibility, Elementary Secondary Education, Grade Repetition, High Risk Students
Peer reviewedRumberger, Russell W. – American Educational Research Journal, 1995
Using data from the National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988 with hierarchical linear modeling, this study identified individual-level and school-level variables influencing the decision to drop out of middle school. At the individual level, grade retention is the single most powerful predictor. (SLD)
Descriptors: Decision Making, Dropout Research, Dropouts, Grade Repetition
Peer reviewedDawson, Margaret M.; Ott, Charles A. – PTA Today, 1991
Sometimes, parents must decide whether to have their child repeat a grade. Research indicates children who stay back do not do better than comparable children who are promoted and retention can have a very negative effect. The article guides parents on what to do and ask in such a situation. (SM)
Descriptors: Academic Failure, Decision Making, Elementary Education, Grade Repetition
Peer reviewedNye, Barbara – ERS Spectrum, 1993
Shows how multiage grouping in the primary grades can support school improvement. Acknowledging chronological age as a crude indicator of learning readiness, multiage programs emphasize grouping children within classes based on readiness, interest, and/or acquired knowledge. This article explains program benefits, disadvantages, implementation…
Descriptors: Change Strategies, Class Organization, Educational Change, Grade Repetition
Peer reviewedCorman, Hope; Chaikind, Stephen – Economics of Education Review, 1998
Examines school performance and behavior of children with low birthweights (less than 2500 grams), compared with a group of normal-birthweight children, using 1988 Health Interview Survey data and controlling for family socioeconomic characteristics. Low-birthweight children are more likely to repeat a grade and attend special-education classes,…
Descriptors: Academic Achievement, Behavior Problems, Birth Weight, Child Health
Peer reviewedHargrove, Tracy Y.; Jones, M. Gail; Jones, Brett D.; Hardin, Belinda; Chapman, Lisa; Davis, Marcia – ERS Spectrum, 2000
Examines some negative consequences of North Carolina's statewide testing system, based on perceptions of 236 elementary teachers. Respondents reported high levels of stress and lower morale, a narrowed curriculum, and decreased student love of learning. They also believed widespread grade repetition was inevitable. (Contains 15 references.) (MLH)
Descriptors: Elementary Education, Faculty Workload, Grade Repetition, High Stakes Tests
Olson, Carl O. – School Administrator, 1999
Ending all social promotion is ill-advised. A responsible decision on grade retention should be based on factors such as a child's age, health, maturity, testing readiness, previous academic performance, and available emedial services. Many retained children do not show enough improvement to justify the practice. (MLH)
Descriptors: Academic Failure, Elementary Education, Grade Repetition, Parent Attitudes
Nord, Christine Winquist; West, Jerry – Education Statistics Quarterly, 2001
Examined parents' school involvement by family type and explored the association between their involvement and whether students get mostly A's, have ever repeated a grade, or have ever been suspended or expelled. Data from the National Household Education Survey indicate that school involvement is not the same across family types, and that…
Descriptors: Academic Achievement, Elementary Secondary Education, Expulsion, Family Structure
Brulle, Andrew R. – Phi Delta Kappan, 2005
Several recent articles articles have emphasized that educators must begin to speak out strongly about the direction that the standards movement is taking. While many positive outcomes have been realized as education has become more accountable, a series of recent education policy decisions have flown directly in the face of many years of…
Descriptors: Federal Legislation, Teacher Educators, Educational Policy, Educational Change
Bali, Valentina A.; Anagnostopoulos, Dorothea; Roberts, Reginald – Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 2005
Policies that mandate in-grade retention of low-performing students have become central components of standards-based reforms across the country. While educational researchers have extensively studied the student-level correlates of retention and the consequences of retention for student achievement, little attention has been focused on…
Descriptors: Grade Repetition, Politics of Education, Educational Change, School Districts
Rafferty, Yvonne; Shinn, Marybeth; Weitzman, Beth C. – Journal of School Psychology, 2004
This study examined the school experiences and academic achievement of 46 adolescents in families who experienced homelessness and 87 permanently housed adolescents whose families received public assistance. Measures taken after the homeless students were rehoused showed that both groups valued school highly and were similar in cognitive abilities…
Descriptors: Cognitive Ability, Adolescents, Standardized Tests, Grade Repetition
Cyr, Mireille; McDuff, Pierre; Wright, John; Theriault, Chantal; Cinq-Mars, Caroline – Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 2005
This study investigated self-harming behaviors in 149 female adolescent victims of sexual abuse, first, by determining the rates of nine types of self-mutilating behavior at intake and nine months later and, second, by investigating comorbidity of clinical correlates associated with these behaviors. The adolescents were divided into three groups…
Descriptors: Sexual Abuse, Self Destructive Behavior, Adolescents, Females

Direct link
